Minnesota: Rethink Weed Control If You Planted Early This Year

Early weed flush. Photo: Dave Nicolai, University of Minnesota

Early weed flush. Photo: Dave Nicolai, University of Minnesota

Planting has progressed rapidly this spring across much of Minnesota and a considerable amount of corn and soybean acres were planted by May 4. Progress has been much faster compared to recent years, thanks to below-average precipitation the last 30 days for much of the state.



Warming soils in late April promoted early crop growth but also early-season weed growth, with flushes of giant ragweed, lambsquarters, and even waterhemp occurring in some areas.

The most recent monthly outlook from the National Weather Service Climate Prediction Center indicates drier than normal conditions with below normal temperatures into the first several weeks of May. What does this scenario mean for weed control?

Timely rains for timely control

Where preemergence (PRE) herbicides have been applied, timely rainfall after application will allow “activation,” or movement of the herbicide into the weed seed germination zone. “Activation” is essential for effective weed control. One-half inch of rain is typically adequate for activation. From a practical standpoint, there is little difference among PRE herbicides in how much rainfall is required for activation.

If rainfall does not happen in a timely fashion, incorporation with a rotary hoe or harrow may help move some of the herbicide off of the soil surface. Rotary hoes should be operated at a high speed and are most effective at controlling weeds in the white root stage (germinated but not yet emerged).

Importance of soil moisture in PRE herbicide activity

Dr. Bob Hartzler, Extension Weeds Specialist at Iowa State University, in a recent article (here), discusses some key points regarding the importance of rainfall for effective control with a PRE herbicide.



  • An important role of rainfall is to keep a portion of the herbicide dissolved in the soil solution so the chemical can be absorbed by germinating seeds. Residual herbicides are less active in dry soil due to less herbicide being in solution.
  • “Reactivation”, “recharge”, or “reach back”, where a PRE herbicide can provide control of weeds that escaped due to dry conditions, can occur with Group 27 herbicides (i.e. HPPD inhibitors in products such as Balance Flexx and Acuron). These products still perform best when they are absorbed during germination.
  • Most PRE herbicides used today are resilient from photodegradation and volatilization, and tend to be more persistent under dry conditions, so they should still be there when rainfall does occur.

Importance of of layering PRE herbicides with early planting dates

Layering a PRE herbicide, where a PRE residual herbicide is applied at planting and then approximately 30 days later (i.e. Group 15), can enhance control of weeds like waterhemp that have an extended emergence period. With earlier planting dates this year, layering of PRE herbicides can provide even greater benefits to an effective weed management program.

  • Earlier planting means that pre-plant tillage removed few, if any, weeds prior to planting, as very few weeds were emerged by late April. Thus, a significant percentage of the weed seedbank has yet to emerge. This places greater emphasis on the ability of the PRE and POST herbicide applications to provide season-long weed control.
  • With an early planting date, a lower concentration of the residual herbicide applied at planting will remain by early to mid-July, which is peak emergence time for waterhemp.
  • It is difficult to predict how effective canopy closure will be on weed control in a given year. Layering with a group 15 herbicide about 30 days after planting will provide an effective concentration of residual herbicide later in the season. This is especially helpful in controlling late-emerging weeds like waterhemp.
  • PRE herbicides are essential tools in controlling herbicide-resistant weeds like waterhemp, giant ragweed and common ragweed. 

Research demonstrated effectiveness of layered approach

University of MN research conducted in 2015 and 2016 demonstrated the effectiveness of a layered preemergence residual herbicide program on weed control with early planting dates. Although planting occurred early in the season (May 4 and May 5, respectively), POST applications of group 15 residual herbicides were still made 30 days after planting. The goal was to keep an effective concentration of herbicide in the soil to prevent waterhemp emergence.

This study also demonstrated that it was better to layer the herbicides 25-30 days after planting, rather than waiting until 40-45 days after planting. The longer 40-45 day interval allowed some weeds to emerge and escape control. Group 15 herbicides kill weeds before they emerge, below the soil surface, and are ineffective on emerged weeds.



The key for 2020

There are more effective postemergence herbicide tools now compared to 2015 and 2016 to help control emerged waterhemp.

If you trust that your postemergence herbicides (Liberty, Enlist, Xtend) will control emerged waterhemp, you may be able to stretch the application window beyond the 30 day recommendation (we waited 42-days in our study). We did this to extend residual control later into July.

In 2015 and 2016, however, we had a closed soybean canopy by early July. The closed canopy provided suppression and “control”of waterhemp that emerged later in the season. Any emerged weeds missed by the postemergence herbicide program were there the rest of the season.

Rainfall is still essential for layered residual herbicides to be effective, so earlier application is preferable in situations where extended-range forecasts may be drier than normal. Otherwise, weeds may germinate and emerge after postemergence applications but before the residual herbicides are “activated.”

Source URL: https://blog-crop-news.extension.umn.edu/2020/05/cool-and-dry-forecast-how-does-that.html