Iowa: Preemergence Herbicide Application Timings – Pros and Cons

Planting and applying pre-emerge herbicide. ©Debra L Ferguson

Planting and applying pre-emerge herbicide. ©Debra L Ferguson

Preemergence herbicides are the foundation of herbicide-based weed management systems, and effective use of these products is essential to protect crop yields and reduce selection pressure for herbicide resistant weeds.



In a perfect world, applying preemergence herbicides immediately after planting would provide the greatest likelihood of maximum performance, but equipment and labor availability limit many farms from using this approach.

This article will provide a brief overview of the pros and cons of different application strategies.

Early preplant: Applications made more than 7 to 10 days prior to planting.

Pros

Cons

  • Applications typically completed before summer annual weeds begin to germinate, thus increasing the likelihood of timely activation by rainfall.
  • May provide a weed-free seedbed at planting. In no-till systems, include a burndown product to control emerged winter annual and other weeds.
  • Application completed before planting, spreading workload.
  • Residual activity into the growing season is shorter than when product is applied near planting. Use of layered residual (including a residual with postemergence application) approach reduces this risk.
  • Final seedbed preparation tillage may ‘dilute’ the herbicide within the soil profile if tool is run too deep, and may result in uneven distribution of the herbicide.
  • Planter units may move herbicide out of the crop row, allowing weed escapes
  • If planting is delayed, much of the value of the herbicide may be lost.

 

Preplant/Preemergence: Applications made within a week before or after planting.

Pros

Cons

  • Product applied near time that summer annuals initiate emergence.
  • Residual control extended later into growing season than early preplant applications.
  • If rain doesn’t occur within a week of planting, early-emerging weeds may escape  control due to lack of herbicide activation.
  • Planter units may move herbicide out of the crop row if applied preplant, allowing weed escapes.

 

Delayed preemergence: Applications made more than a week after planting.

Pros

Cons

  • May spread workload.
  • Residual control is extended later into growing season.
  • Herbicide options may be reduced if crop has emerged before application.
  • Summer annual weeds likely will have emerged at application, requiring additional postemergence product to control these weeds.
  • Rainfall is needed within a few days of the application to activate product.
  • Application delays can result in early-season competition between crops and weeds, and may allow weeds to exceed optimum size for postemergence control.

Herbicide resistant weeds have limited our ability to ‘rescue’ fields when weather delays preemergence applications following planting.  Thus, consider how you can ensure that all acres are protected with appropriate preemergence herbicide applications when prolonged wet periods or other factors interfere with field operations.  

Source URL: https://crops.extension.iastate.edu/cropnews/2020/04/preemergence-herbicide-application-timings-pros-and-cons